4 star, YA

Review: Scythe by Neal Shusterman

Series: Arc of a Scythe #1

scythe -neal shustermanTwo teens are forced to murder—maybe each other—in the first in a chilling new series from Neal Shusterman, author of the New York Times bestselling Unwind dystology.

Thou shalt kill.

In a world where disease has been eliminated, the only way to die is to be randomly killed (“gleaned”) by professional reapers (“scythes”). Citra and Rowan are teenagers who have been selected to be scythe’s apprentices, and—despite wanting nothing to do with the vocation—they must learn the art of killing and come to understand the necessity of what they do.

Only one of them will be chosen as a scythe’s apprentice. And when it becomes clear that the winning apprentice’s first task will be to glean the loser, Citra and Rowan are pitted against one another in a fight for their lives.


4 Drink Me Potions


What can I say about Scythe?

Honestly? After taking a couple of days to think about it since finishing this book, I’m not sure I can put it into any better words. But here IS what I would say.

Scythe is deeply thought-provoking and makes you question bigger things such as morality and good and evil. Who is allowed to take a life? At what cost would this come? How does human nature tie into it all? Can you maintain your own soul when you are charged to take lives as a duty, over and over again?

All these things swirled in my mind as I was reading this book. And this book could be read pretty quickly but I had to take my time with it.

Citra and Rowan were both ordinary individuals living out their boring day-to-day lives. Very rarely do people around them die – otherwise known as being gleaned in this somewhat far off society on Earth. But then they both encounter a scythe and life as they know it becomes completely different.

I loved reading their stories from both their perspectives. It may not have been first person, but it was still really descriptive about their thoughts and feelings as they trained as apprentices to a Scythe Master. I loved the snippets at the end of each chapter that took insight into certain Scythe Masters’ thoughts about what they did and why they did it. Although they may seem random at first, everything tied together well in the end.

I felt that Neal Shusterman did an amazing job building this world that seems plausible as technology and data grows. But the most amazing feat he accomplished was the ability to capture complexity of human conscience and the in-between gray areas behind people’s intentions and actions. That is what kept me going throughout this book.

The only reason I couldn’t give this a full 5 star rating was my annoyance with Rowan at times. I’m not sure what to make of him nearer to the end, although I do hold out some hope that things are going to more than what they seem. Yes, I know that sounds vague but let’s not give away anything too much, right?

As for romance, I was so sure that there’d be more between Rowan and Citra but they weren’t together all that much in the story to truly develop anything stronger than attraction in my mind. I’m not sure what the ending implied but I look forward to seeing what’s to come for the both of them and the whole Scythedom as some crazy things really shake up its workings then.

Overall Recommendation:
Scythe provided a wonderful platform for a story about morality behind every action. As a Scythe or even as a simple apprentice, our protagonists Rowan and Citra learned so much about the workings of their immortal society and the role of scythes that is far more complex than simply killing a certain quota of individuals. In such a complex world that may not be so far off into the future, Shusterman did an amazing job building a believable society and its own problems that need to be solved. Overall, this story was one that made me think and it followed me long after I closed the last page.

4 star, YA

Review: Fireblood by Elly Blake

Series: Frostblood Saga #2

fireblood -elly blakeAll hail the Fire Queen.

Against all odds, Ruby has defeated the villainous Frost King and melted his throne of ice. But the bloodthirsty Minax that was trapped inside is now haunting her kingdom and everyone she loves. The answers to its demise may lie to the south in Sudesia, the land of the Firebloods, and a country that holds the secrets to Ruby’s powers and past…

Despite warnings from her beloved Arcus, Ruby accompanies a roguish Fireblood named Kai to Sudesia, where she must master her control of fire in a series of trials to gain the trust of the suspicious Fire Queen. Only then can she hope to access the knowledge that could defeat the rampaging Minax—which grows closer every moment. But as sparks fly in her moments alone with Kai, Ruby no longer knows whom to trust.

The fates of two kingdoms are now in her hands.


4 Drink Me Potions


Let me just say that hands down, this novel restores my faith in authors who can make amazing sequels that may even surpass the original novel, especially one where I could see its potential for greatness. Fireblood was both exhilarating and fast-paced while building more on top of this world’s history and ideologies. I would say that is a huge feat.

This story focuses on Ruby’s journey and mission in her home country of Sudesia. I loved learning more about this place and the Fireblood masters’ abilities. There were so many more facets of Ruby’s powers and background that just became more clear in this book as she never really related to the Frostbloods.

Never fear, Frostblood lovers. There were snippets still in Tempesia, though this was mostly restricted to the beginning. I enjoyed seeing the aftermath of book 1 and how things weren’t as rosy as our protagonists had hoped. Frostbloods are still racist and probably secretly hoping for Ruby’s head on a stick!

What came with this was seeing Ruby’s relationship with Arcus now that his mission to take the throne was accomplished. The one thing that made this less than a perfect rating is the somewhat limited amount of interaction with him in this book. Clearly he’s not headed to Sudesia with her unless he has a secret death wish. That’d be irresponsible of him. While Arcus isn’t featured as heavily as book 1, for all you Arcus lovers out there, he’s still relevant as I’ll explain in a moment.

Another main thing that occurs in this book is the introduction of Kai, a charming Fireblood who I can’t decide whether I love him or not. There’s definitely an attraction of sorts between him and Ruby, but honestly, it doesn’t bloom into a hard choice for her to pick between the two suitors. So I wouldn’t necessarily classify him as a love triangle but that brings me to question why any of this was even introduced in the first place. Don’t get me wrong, I love Kai as a fun and easygoing friend in this book, but I’m not sure I see the relevance of being potential competition for Arcus when Ruby spent a lot of time pining away for him.

This is where Arcus is still relevant. He makes his appearances in the book beyond just the very beginning (don’t you worry, I’m Team Arcus all the way) although a huge part of me yearned for more interactions between him and Ruby like in book 1. There were romantic tensions that occurred near the beginning when they separated that had my heartstrings crying out for closure and it definitely hastened my page-flipping to see how it all tied up at the end. Without ruining much, I believe Elly handled it amazingly – even with the “love triangle” present for which I’m never a huge fan of in any book – and that’s not usually the case for me and love triangles. Honestly, we just don’t mix very well. So that says something.

Aside from romantic entanglements and such, the last 100 pages had me gripped in a breathless frenzy. Everything’s setting the stage for the big conclusion, and while some things weren’t necessarily unpredictable, I still really enjoyed how it got there and the revelations about Ruby that unfolded slowly. Little tidbits really are starting to fall into place and I’m so looking forward to what the last book brings! Can next year come a little closer? Please?

Overall Recommendation:

Fireblood is the rarity that excels beyond its predecessor, a marvellous feat that has shown us that Elly Blake can really craft a wonderful story that ties so well together beyond a single book. With more world building and character development in Ruby, the pages really go by fast as new revelations are made and relationships are tested. While not truly a love triangle themed story in my opinion, the additional characters introduced in this sequel gave the overall cast more diversity and molded different sides to our favourite protagonists. Honestly? I just cannot wait to get my hands on book 3, Nightblood. And you should too.

Note: meeting the author had in no way biased or affected my review on this novel as I look at a book for what it is regardless of my (positive or negative) feelings about the author.